In this interview, casting directors Jessica Kelly (Euphoria, Y2K) and Lisa Parasyn (Schitt’s Creek, Lost Girl) share what it took to cast the new comedy series Overcompensating, from collaborating with Benito Skinner to finding actors who could bring both humor and heart to their roles.
They discuss what makes an actor stand out in auditions, the challenges of casting cameos for a new series, and why empathy and authenticity are key ingredients in a memorable performance. Plus, they offer their best advice for self-tapes, including why your first few moments on camera are crucial, and why it’s essential to know your lines.
If you’re an actor looking to improve your audition game or simply curious about the casting process behind one of this year’s buzziest new shows, this interview is packed with valuable insights.
Timestamps:
• (00:02) Intro
• (00:44 - 01:31) Jessica explains her connection to A24 and Jonah Hill’s company, which led her to the project. She brought Lisa on to cast the Canadian roles.
• (02:13) Initially, only Benito Skinner was attached to Overcompensating. Mary Beth Barone had to audition despite the role being written for her.
• (02:52 - 04:07) Benito was very involved, reading with actors in auditions.
• (04:43 - 05:28) The casting process included over 100 roles and many cameos. Casting big names and surprise cameos was challenging since the show was unproven at the time.
• (06:04 - 07:33) Actors who brought truth and natural humor stood out. Holmes was highlighted as a standout for her unexpected and brilliant performances.
• (08:11 - 09:25) Jessica received 6,000–8,000 submissions for one role.
• (10:49 - 12:02) Many actors submitted similar reads for each audition. Those who stood out brought heart and individuality, rather than just broad comedy. Authenticity and connection to the character were vital.
• (12:38 - 13:20) Memorable actors are those who show empathy and depth, not just technical skill or charisma. They can deliver simple, authentic performances that suggest an inner life.
• (13:59 - 15:13) Self-tape advice for Actors
If you liked this video, please be sure to subscribe! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsjy6It6J9BTVdL0NVNGDsQ?sub_confirmation=1
DAILY ACTOR: https://www.dailyactor.com
FOLLOW DAILY ACTOR:
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/dailyactor
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/dailyactor/
Threads: https://www.threads.net/@dailyactor
Twitter/X: http://www.twitter.com/DailyActor
Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com/thedailyactor/
#Overcompensating #CastingDirectors #JessicaKelly #LisaParasyn #BenitoSkinner #ActingTips #SelfTapeTips #CastingAdvice #OvercompensatingInterview #DailyActor #ActorsLife #AuditionTips #TVCasting #BehindTheScenes
1