Movie Review: ‘The Giver’

The-Giver

The Giver, based on a wildly popular young adult novel by Lois Lowry, is a huge disappointment.

The film has a nice cast – Jeff Bridges as the Giver, Meryl Streep, Alexander Skarsgard, Katie Holmes and Brenton Thwaites. But as good as they are, they can’t salvage this mess.

The world of The Giver is a colorless (literally), utopian society. There are no wars or suffering. No pain, no lies… no fun. The society is governed (ruled) by Chief Elder (Streep) and a handful of nondescript Secondary Elders. I guess that’s what their called because it was never explained. The townsfolk have no memories of anything. No history, no past. They don’t even know how to clap properly (they take one hand and slap it on their leg). The only one who remembers the past and how to clap is The Giver (Bridges).

We then get a scene that’s straight out of Harry Potter but since The Giver was written way before Potter my mind is exploding. The town is gathered together and the names of the young people are called out. They walk on stage and are told what their job in life will be: birth mother, drone pilot, geneticist and a Giver.

Jonas (Thwaites, who was very good in The Signal) is the town’s new Giver. He’s tasked with learning all of the secrets from Bridge’s Giver but he soon realizes that his town isn’t the nice, family society he thought it was.

Directed by Phillip Noyce, the first part of the film has an early 50’s Disney feel to it. It’s shot in black and white and everything is perfect. Trouble is, most modern black and white films have a depth to them; deep and rich blacks, whites and greys. This b&w has no depth to it. It’s flat and lifeless.

But, that’s because the town is flat and lifeless. Their lives are flat and lifeless.

And that’s a huge problem as an audience member.

The characters, except for Bridges, Streep and Thwaites, are emotionless and bland. The actors seem like they’re acting like humanoids, complete with really bad dialogue. What may have been interesting in the book does not work here in the film. How are we supposed to connect with characters that have no life behind their eyes?

There are way too many close-ups too. Again, the audience needs to see what’s happening in the scene to connect with the characters. Maybe Noyce added them to show that the main character weren’t emotionless. “Let’s show Bridges in close-up. He’s got life in those eyes!”

By the time Jonas starts to rebel and color seeps back into the world, it’s too late. My mind was wandering and I started to think what I was going to eat for dinner. Something that wasn’t bland I was hoping.

Leave a Reply

Latest Videos

http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/sag-foundation-conversation-with.jpg
SAG Foundation Conversation with the Cast of NBC’s ‘Marry Me’
Earlier this month NBC put in an order for five additional episodes of its freshman romantic comedy series, Marry Me. While that isn’t exactly the shot of confidence that a full-season renewal provides, it’s enough to keep fans of the comedy — which is about an engaged couple who are determined to get married despite […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/michael-caine.jpg
Michael Caine Talks About Acting With Your Eyes and Does an Amazing Cold Read of a Script
This week acting legend Michael Caine appears in his sixth film directed by Christopher Nolan, Interstellar. In an interview clip from The New York Times that was shot around the release of the last movie Caine worked on with Nolan, The Dark Knight Rises, reporter Melena Ryzik spoke to Caine about his six-decade career. In […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/director-dan-gilroy-narrates-a-s.jpg
Director Dan Gilroy Narrates a Scene from ‘Nightcrawler’ Featuring Jake Gyllenhaal and Rene Russo
Nightcrawler is easily one of the best movies of the year and its star, Jake Gyllenhaal, is outstanding. Definitely check this out when you have a chance. In the above clip, writer/director Dan Gilroy narrates a sequence from the film that features Gyllenhaal and Rene Russo. He talks about giving Gyllenhaal a small piece of […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/matthew-mcconaughey-talks-losing.png
Matthew McConaughey Talks Losing the Lead Role in ‘Bernie’ to Jack Black
Though Matthew McConaughey has increased his earned plenty of respect since he started taking on more substantive movie roles in the last few years (with Dallas Buyers Club even earning him an Oscar for Best Actor), one director that always has been a fan of McConaughey is Richard Linklater. Linklater gave McConaughey his first big […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/watch-benedict-cumberbatch-film.jpg
Watch: Benedict Cumberbatch Film the Smaug Motion Capture for ‘The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug’
Though Peter Jackson‘s movie adaptations of The Hobbit haven’t received the same critical acclaim as his films based on the book’s sequel, The Lord of the Rings (turning a 300 page book into 9+ hours of film tends to do that), fans are still eagerly anticipating the release of the final part of The Hobbit […]