One Redhead per Show – An Important Audition Lesson

  • Pin It

Written by Sean Pratt

One good way to explain the casting process to actors is the concept of GOOD vs. USEFUL

This a process a director uses to see if the “good” actor can be “useful” for their project. Understanding the difference between being “good” and “useful”, and how it relates to whether or not you get the part, is one of the most important ideas you can grasp, as it relates to auditioning. Let’s explore it in a more detail.

Good vs. Bad

To start with, children are rewarded for being good and an adult is rewarded for being useful. What this means is, if a child follows the rules and does what they are told, they will usually be rewarded. The child learns that this can be relied upon in most situations dealing with an authority figure. Generally speaking, until you leave school for the working world, you have been functioning under this system.

Good vs. Useful

However, in the BIZ, you will get hired only if the director and/or producer deem you “useful” no matter how “good” you are. Yes, you must be “good.” That is, you must have talent and be able to show it in the audition, but that’s merely the beginning. You will be hired on the merits of how useful you are to the project; i.e., she handles verse well, he’s the right age, she’s got the right feel for this character. Many actors don’t want to hear this. They say, “Why am I not being rewarded with the part; at the audition I was ‘good’.” (Meaning they were prepared, on time, and professional). To illustrate this mind set, here’s a little story.

Broadway Bound

Once, back in 1995, there was a young actor in named…Shane. He got an excited call from his agent, Louie, telling him he had his first Broadway audition. It was for a comedy set in the 1950’s and Shane was to read for a part that Louie said he was perfect for. Naturally, he grabbed the sides and started feverishly working on his audition scene, all the while hearing Ethel Merman sing…There’s No Business like Show Business in his head.

When he walked into the audition room on the big day, Shane was a bit taken aback; he had never seen so many people on the other side of the table before. The director was there, the producers were there, the costume people, the choreographer…and all their minions. It was a little off-putting to say the least, but Shane was ready and when the director said, “Go ahead”, he jumped right in. Now, you know that feeling when you’re auditioning for a comedy and they’re actually laughing at all your stuff? Well, Shane’s timing was really on the mark that day because they were hooting it up and with every guffaw, Ethel Merman’s dulcet voice got a little louder…Next day on your dressing room they’ve hung a star!

That Was Great…But

When Shane finished the scene the director got up and came over to talk to him. He thought, “Great! He’s going to give me some direction and I’ll have another chance to wow them!” He put his hand on Shane’s shoulder and said, “Shane, you’re a very funny actor and I know you’ll do well in this business, but unfortunately there’s only going to be one redhead in this show. Thank you for your time.” Ethel’s voice was replaced by the sound of the record needle scratching across the LP. Now being a redheaded had never been easy for Shane. He’d grown up looking like an orange on a toothpick and was teased mercilessly for it. But to find out that that was the only reason he was being shown the door, really stung.

You see, the play Shane was auditioning for was MOON OVER BUFFALO which was to be Carol Burnett’s comeback vehicle for Broadway and of course she would be sporting her famous strawberry blonde hair. So, though he did a “good” job at the audition, Shane just wasn’t “useful” to the director.

The Moral of the Story

Some of you might be thinking, “Well, they could have dyed his hair or wigged him!” This is true, but they didn’t have to. They knew that there would be another actor out there who would be “good” and, because he wouldn’t have red hair, would also be “useful.” It was a tough lesson to learn, but one Shane never forgot.


Sean Pratt
, (AEA / SAG / AFTRA), has been a working actor for over 20 years. Sean was a member of the resident acting company at The Pearl Theatre, an Off-Broadway classical repertory theatre and has also performed at numerous regional theatres around the country.  Major films include – Gods and Generals, Tuck Everlasting and Iron Jawed Angels. Television work includes – The host of HGTV’s, Old Homes Restored, and supporting roles on Homicide, The District and America’s Most Wanted.  Audiobooks – He’s narrated for 15 years and has recorded nearly 550 books in just about every genre.  He also teaches classes on and writes articles about the business of the Biz.

Leave a Reply

http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/watch-al-pacino-talks-the-humbli.jpg
Watch: Al Pacino Talks ‘The Humbling’ and His Extraordinary Career
In this conversation with Al Pacino talks about his role in The Humbling -- including working with Greta Gerwig -- and his historic acting career
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/watch-oscar-nominee-steve-carell.jpg
Watch: Oscar Nominee Steve Carell Talks Improv, Auditioning for ‘The Office’ and ‘Foxcatcher’
Carell talks about his entire career as an actor, including his background in improv, how he landed the Michael Scott role on The Office, and Foxcatcher
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/ethan-hawke-ellar-coltrane-boyhood.jpg
Ethan Hawke Calls ‘Boyhood’ the “most special endeavor of my life”
Ethan Hawke is riding high with his fourth Oscar nomination for the Richard Linklater-directed Boyhood. In a recent “Ask Me Anything” on Reddit, the 44-year-old actor gave some thoughtful insight into his career and the 12-year creative endeavor that became the biggest film of the Oscar season. When asked what was the most difficult thing about […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/martha-plimpton-a-delicate-balance.jpg
Martha Plimpton Takes a Refreshing Approach to a Long-Lasting Career
Martha Plimpton is an actress who enjoys the work, she’s not in it for the fame. The proof is in her continually excellent work that she is doing on-screen and on the stage. She’s currently starring in A Delicate Balance on Broadway. It’s the audience who gives her the ultimate thrill. “I try to get […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/watch-michael-keaton-talks-candi.jpg
Watch: Michael Keaton Talks Candidly About His Career and His Approach to Acting in ‘Birdman’
In this nearly 90 minute conversation, Michael Keaton is his usual affable self but is also remarkably candid about his career and his approach to acting.