The Role That Got Away: Will Chase on Returning to ‘Something Rotten!’

Actor Will Chase in Broadway's 'Something Rotten'

“I know that I am a poor man’s fill-in-the-blank. And I know that there are poor man’s Will Chases out there. That’s just the nature of the business.” – Will Chase

Almost any actor will tell you about “the one that got away.” In their case, it’s usually not a person — it’s a role they really, really wanted but had to turn down for whatever reason. In the case of Nashville star Will Chase, he has had the opportunity to get back to the role that got away. Last month he joined Broadway’s Something Rotten! to play an over-the-top version of William Shakespeare — a role that, as he tells the Associated Press, he had to pass on several years ago.

Chase appeared as Shakespeare in workshops of Something Rotten!, but he had to pull out of the show in order to do Nashville. As it turns out, Christian Borle — Chase’s former Smash co-star — not only took the role, but he also won a Tony for it. However, don’t ask Chase to curse his luck. He says, “Ten years ago, I might be bitter and jaded about it. But no. It’s truly a treat to see how far it’s come and to have been a part of those early things.”

Of course, it happens both ways — Chase was nominated for a Tony in 2013 for his performance in the revival of The Mystery of Edwin Drood, which was a role he wasn’t originally slated for. He says, “I’ve been given roles that people have turned down. I won’t say who turned down the role that I got my Tony nomination for, but somebody turned down that role. They weren’t like, ‘Get Will Chase in here now! He’s going to win a Tony nomination for this!’ So I know that I am a poor man’s fill-in-the-blank. And I know that there are poor man’s Will Chases out there. That’s just the nature of the business.”

Chase has a long history of appearing in musicals — mainly comedies — on Broadway dating back to the late 1990s. Even with all that experience, he admits it’s still challenging. He says, “Comedy is terrifying. Comedy is a terrifying prospect. But when it happens, it’s like a drug. And I’m enjoying taking that drug.”

But despite the “terrifying” aspect, he has been in love with acting since a friend convinced him to act in a summer stock production while he was in college for music. He recalls, “I fell in love with it. I was like, ‘OK, I’m cutting my ponytail.’ The day I graduated, I got my diploma, I moved to Chicago and started acting.”

As a result, Chase gets to return to doing what he loves — even if he had to pass this specific role up once before.

Leave a Reply
Luke Evans on Being Cast in Beauty and the Beast and the “Huge Moment” He Had Early in His Career
"It's a validation that you are the right person for the job because they've chosen and they've seen you do something connected to that role." - Luke Evans on Auditioning
Parker Posey on Her Improv Skills: “I still don’t think I’m actually good at it”
"Every time I do something, I worry it’s my last job... I think that’s normal though." - Parker Posey
William H. Macy: “This may sound pretentious, but I am getting better at what I do every day”
"I love the fact that I work every day." - William H. Macy
Luke Hemsworth on ‘Westworld’: “It was a no-brainer to me. I was absolutely going to jump onboard”
"As an actor, if you're given very little information about what's going on, then you're forced to make it up." - Luke Hemsworth
Khary Payton on His ‘Walking Dead’ Audition: “It was one of the more substantial auditions I’ve ever done”
"I always say I’m in the hope business. You’ve got to stay hopeful. You’ve got to get up off your behind and try again..." - Khary Payton