Review: ‘The Truth About Emanuel’ Starring Kaya Scodelario and Jessica Biel

the-truth-about-emanuel-poster

The Truth About Emanuel, writer/director’s Francesca Gregorini sophomore effort, is a puzzling sort of film. Not in a bad way but also not in the best of ways either.

Emanuel (Kaya Scodelario from the U.K.’s Skins) is seventeen years old and thinks she’s not supposed to be here, as in alive. She’s walking around with the guilt of her mother dying while giving birth to her and she’s carrying this notion that she’s a “murderer.” That’s heavy stuff for a young girl to deal with and as the story begins, she’s in full-on ‘acting out’ mode, Not in the rebellious sense, more of a shock value sense (like telling her step-mother about a recent sex dream.)

When the new neighbor, single mother Linda (Jessica Biel), says she’s looking for a babysitter, Emanuel agrees to help out. Linda’s a doting and protective mother who seems a bit off. She wears long flowing dresses and non-period clothes and always has a faraway look in her eyes.

We quickly find out the reason why she seems so odd: Her baby isn’t real. It’s a doll.

Emaunel’s discovery of the fake baby doesn’t push her away from Linda though; it brings her closer and makes her more protective. She makes huge efforts to always get in the way every time Linda might show off the baby to someone.

Is the reason she’s doing this because Emaunel is a bit off as well? She’s randomly seeing things that aren’t there. Is she damaged the way Linda is? Is that the truth about Emanuel?

Unfortunately, the truth isn’t all that interesting. I kept waiting for some ‘a-ha’ moment in her story but it never arrived. The real truth lies in Linda and why she’s caring for a doll-baby. And when we find that out, that’s the best moment of the film.

The film starts off great; a psychological drama that seems to be adding the building blocks of its story in perfect place. As the film unfolds though, we begin to realize that the story isn’t as deep as we think it’s going to be and the easily wrapped up ending disappoints.

The performances are all fine. Scodelario and Biel work wonders with some of the stilted and clichéd dialogue and it was nice to see Biel in a role she doesn’t usually get to play. Her moments after the baby reveal are quite good. Alfred Molina, as Emanuel’s put upon father, is always a joy to watch. He took a character that we’ve seen hundreds of times and made it solely his own.

Gregorini’s story about loss and how people deal with it is like an English language foreign film. The way it feels and its style and story reminded me of late 1970’s French films I watched back in college. Not that that is a bad thing. In fact, it made it more interesting. I’d love to see what she does next because she’s definitely an original voice.

The Truth About Emanuel opens at the Reading Gaslamp 15 Friday, January 10th.

It is also opening in the cities below:

New York: Village East – opens January 10
Los Angeles: Los Feliz 3 and the Royal
San Diego, CA: Gaslamp – opens January 10
Phoenix, AZ: Shea 14 – opens January 10
Miami: Shea 14 – opens January 10
Phoenix, AZ: Sunset Place 24 – opens January 10
Denver: Highlands Ranch 24 – opens January 10
Dallas: Grapevine 30 – opens January 10
Houston: Gulf Pointe 30 – opens January 10
Minneapolis: Eden Prairie 18 – opens January 10
Cherry Hill, NJ: Cherry Hill 24 – opens January 10

Leave a Reply

Latest Videos

http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/sag-foundation-conversation-with.jpg
SAG Foundation Conversation with the Cast of NBC’s ‘Marry Me’
Earlier this month NBC put in an order for five additional episodes of its freshman romantic comedy series, Marry Me. While that isn’t exactly the shot of confidence that a full-season renewal provides, it’s enough to keep fans of the comedy — which is about an engaged couple who are determined to get married despite […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/michael-caine.jpg
Michael Caine Talks About Acting With Your Eyes and Does an Amazing Cold Read of a Script
This week acting legend Michael Caine appears in his sixth film directed by Christopher Nolan, Interstellar. In an interview clip from The New York Times that was shot around the release of the last movie Caine worked on with Nolan, The Dark Knight Rises, reporter Melena Ryzik spoke to Caine about his six-decade career. In […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/director-dan-gilroy-narrates-a-s.jpg
Director Dan Gilroy Narrates a Scene from ‘Nightcrawler’ Featuring Jake Gyllenhaal and Rene Russo
Nightcrawler is easily one of the best movies of the year and its star, Jake Gyllenhaal, is outstanding. Definitely check this out when you have a chance. In the above clip, writer/director Dan Gilroy narrates a sequence from the film that features Gyllenhaal and Rene Russo. He talks about giving Gyllenhaal a small piece of […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/matthew-mcconaughey-talks-losing.png
Matthew McConaughey Talks Losing the Lead Role in ‘Bernie’ to Jack Black
Though Matthew McConaughey has increased his earned plenty of respect since he started taking on more substantive movie roles in the last few years (with Dallas Buyers Club even earning him an Oscar for Best Actor), one director that always has been a fan of McConaughey is Richard Linklater. Linklater gave McConaughey his first big […]
http://www.dailyactor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/watch-benedict-cumberbatch-film.jpg
Watch: Benedict Cumberbatch Film the Smaug Motion Capture for ‘The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug’
Though Peter Jackson‘s movie adaptations of The Hobbit haven’t received the same critical acclaim as his films based on the book’s sequel, The Lord of the Rings (turning a 300 page book into 9+ hours of film tends to do that), fans are still eagerly anticipating the release of the final part of The Hobbit […]