Even though thousands have seen the film and it has garnered several awards (including a nomination for the Outstanding Performance by a Cast Screen Actors Guild Award), Nicholson admits that the “dream come true” experience still doesn’t feel real, confessing, “I still don’t really believe it, even though the proof is out there.”
Of course, suggesting that Nicholson is a new face ignores all of the roles that she has appeared since her career began in the 1990s, including roles on the popular television series Masters of Sex, Boardwalk Empire, Law & Order: Criminal Intent, and Ally McBeal, among many others.
Still, Nicholson admits that August: Osage County was one of the most challenging roles of her career because of its intensity. She explains, “I found this job to be very hard, mostly just the character and trying to be true to her experience but also living in that place for nine weeks. I don’t bring it home with me but it’s still – I don’t want to give anything away – but some of the things you go through, obviously it’s fake, but your body is going through the actions of these things. So it was very exhausting and I just was trying to do it right.”
So it’s no surprise that Nicholson says that she hopes her next role will be something much lighter. She says, “The last couple of years, I think they’ve all been quite serious, strong, maybe a little tough. I want to play something a little lighter next. The next new job I get … I’d like to do something funny again. I did Ally McBeal, which I loved and a comedy film Seeing Other People, and I feel I’d like to exercise that muscle again. And also let people know that I can smile, I’m not always so flipping unhappy! It’s not because I’m unhappy in my life.”