Levy has not only appeared in all four of the theatrically released American Pie films — including the latest, American Reunion — but he is also the only actor to appear in all four of the straight-to-DVD American Pie Presents films.
Levy talks to Vulture about why he’s stuck with the series so long and how he felt about sharing a scene with Jennifer Coolidge in the latest film.
Unlike most actors, Levy admits that the deciding factor to star in the straight-to-DVD spinoffs was financial, though he did assert a creative role. He explains, “I do separate the straight-to-DVDs from the theatricals. When we did the third American Pie, that was supposed to be it. The DVDs came along, and I don’t want to sound too crass, but it was too good of a job to turn down … they were paying a lot of money for not a lot of work, to be honest. But I did want to protect the character in those movies, so he wouldn’t be seen in a light that would shock or disappoint people. I was able to rewrite [on the fly] and say, ‘Yes, my character will do this.’ Or, ‘No, I won’t stand beside any naked women, la dee dah.'”
Though Levy and Coolidge (Stifler’s Mom) have both appeared in the three previous main American Pie films, the two never shared a scene together in those movies. However, Coolidge and Levy have experience working together in three of Christopher Guest‘s ensemble comedies, and Jim’s Dad and Stifler’s Mom finally share a memorable scene together in American Reunion. Levy points to it as one of the main reasons he enjoyed the latest sequel, saying, “That was an exciting aspect of the story. We got to improvise a lot of stuff. To answer your question, that scene was — I think I could’ve easily said, ‘You know, I don’t think I can go there.’ But, I gave [writer/directors Jon Hurwitz and Hayden Schlossberg] the benefit of the doubt because I trusted them.”